enricobuehler
4f9071b980
Until now there was one Xbox identity, `device_type = 4` / `045E:0B13`, and Windows folded a client's `XboxOne` request onto it because the only Windows Xbox backend was the XUSB companion, which presents one fixed 360 identity and cannot vary it. The HID backend can, so the fold goes and two identities join it: devtype 4 045E:0B13 pf_xboxwireless Xbox Wireless Controller devtype 5 045E:02FD pf_xboxones Xbox Wireless Controller (One S) devtype 6 045E:0B22 pf_xboxelite Xbox Elite Wireless Controller Series 2 `GamepadPref::XboxElite` takes wire byte 11 — the first unassigned one, and the round-trip test previously asserted `from_u8(11) == Auto` with a comment saying assigning it must update that; the sentinel moved to 12. The C ABI mirror and the generated header moved with it. ⭐ ALL THREE SHARE ONE REPORT DESCRIPTOR, deliberately. In HID terms they are the same pad; the descriptor is the report shape, not the identity. §3 of the handoff records that our single hand-written descriptor already cost three separate bugs, and inventing two more would multiply that debt for no measured gain. They differ in VID/PID, product string, hardware id and Device Manager description only. ⚠️ All three install `pfGamepadXbox`, the section that attaches the `xinputhid` bus filter. That was the open risk: Microsoft's `xinputhid.inf` promotes by an explicit hardware-id allow-list containing `02D1, 02DD, 02E3, 02EA, 0B00, 0B0A, 0B13, 02FF` — and NEITHER `02FD` NOR `0B22` is on it. Measured on .173: promotion does not care, because it comes from our own AddReg rather than from matching Microsoft's ids. All three gain `IG_00`, register an XUSB interface, and are read live by classic XInput. Had this gone the other way the two new identities would have been strictly worse than the one they joined. The XUSB escape hatch needed a runtime degrade to stay honest. `pick_gamepad` is compile-time only, so with `PUNKTFUNK_XBOX_BACKEND=xusb` the host would have resolved and echoed `xboxelite` in its `Welcome` while actually building a 360 pad. `degrade_xbox_identity` folds the identity back at runtime, mirroring `degrade_if_no_uhid`. VERIFIED ON WINDOWS (.173 — none of this compiles on macOS; the driver needs the WDK and the rest is `cfg(windows)`): * `cargo test -p pf-inject --lib` 104/104 — including `hwid_matches_inf`, `hwid_devtype_table_matches_the_driver` and `only_the_xbox_identity_installs_the_xinputhid_section`, all now sweeping the whole identity set and asserting the section split in both directions. * `cargo test -p punktfunk-core --lib gamepad` 7/7; `cargo check -p punktfunk-host` clean. * Driver builds and signs; the descriptor/`wReportLength` const asserts still hold with the descriptor shared three ways. * ON GLASS, per identity, via the new `--xboxones` / `--xboxelite` devtest legs: each gets its own devnode (`PF_XBOX_0` / `PF_XBOX_ONES_0` / `PF_XBOX_ELITE_0`), each HID child gains `IG_00`, each registers an XUSB interface, and XInput reads each live (packets advancing, `buttons=0x1000`). * macOS: `cargo fmt --all --check` clean in both workspaces. NOT VERIFIED / NOT DONE * **Elite paddles are NOT implemented.** `BTN_PADDLE1..4` would need descriptor buttons, and once `xinputhid` promotes the pad it claims the HID collection exclusively — XInput has no paddle fields and the HID consumers that do may be locked out, so the buttons would likely reach nobody. The decisive measurement is cheap and named in the code: hold a paddle bit set and see whether a user-mode HID reader still gets reports. Until then the Edge remains the only virtual pad with native back-button slots and nothing should be advertised otherwise. * **No client picker offers the Elite**, and none can auto-detect it — SDL3's `GamepadType` has no Elite variant. It is reachable today only via `PUNKTFUNK_GAMEPAD=xboxelite` or a hand-edited client setting. All five clients ship the same curated six options by deliberate parity, so adding one is a cross-client UX change, not part of this. * Nothing here has run in a real streaming session; every measurement came from the devtest.
Packaging punktfunk for Fedora / Bazzite
The punktfunk host links system FFmpeg (NVENC on NVIDIA, VAAPI on AMD/Intel, with a GPU-less software-H.264 fallback), PipeWire and Opus. This page covers packaging it for the Fedora Atomic / Bazzite world (rpm-ostree + bootc), where most of those deps are already present; the NVIDIA-specific notes below apply to the NVENC path.
👉 Ubuntu/Debian hosts install via
aptfrom Gitea's package registry — seedebian/README.md(apt update && apt upgradefor new builds).
👉 End-to-end Bazzite setup walkthrough (install → udev/group →
host.env→ service → firewall → verify → troubleshooting):bazzite/README.md. This file is the higher-level packaging rationale.
packaging/
rpm/punktfunk.spec # the RPM (builds punktfunk-host from source with cargo)
bazzite/host.env # gamescope-default config for a Bazzite appliance
bazzite/README.md # step-by-step Bazzite setup guide
bazzite/*sysext*.sh # the no-layering path: build/install/publish the systemd-sysext
bootc/Containerfile # bake punktfunk into a Bazzite-based atomic image
copr/ # COPR build-from-SCM settings
The other packaging targets have their own READMEs: debian/ (apt),
arch/ (pacman binary repo + PKGBUILD + SteamOS sysext),
flatpak/ (the client), windows/ (host installer +
drivers), plus kde/ and linux/ helpers. NixOS / Nix users get a flake (flake.nix at the
repo root) with reproducible host + client packages and a services.punktfunk NixOS module —
see nix/README.md.
What's needed beyond base Fedora
| Dependency | Where it comes from |
|---|---|
ffmpeg-libs with NVENC |
RPM Fusion nonfree (ffmpeg, not ffmpeg-free) |
NVIDIA driver (libnvidia-encode, libEGL_nvidia) |
Bazzite -nvidia images ship it; plain Fedora: akmod-nvidia + xorg-x11-drv-nvidia-cuda |
| gamescope, PipeWire, wireplumber | Bazzite ships these; plain Fedora: dnf install gamescope pipewire wireplumber |
opus, libei |
Fedora base / updates |
On Bazzite the only genuinely new runtime bits are ffmpeg-libs (RPM Fusion) + opus +
libei — the rest of the stack is already there. The default backend is gamescope
(packaging/bazzite/host.env), which the host spawns headless per session — no desktop login.
Option A — systemd-sysext (recommended; no layering, no reboot)
On Bazzite / Fedora Atomic the recommended install is the systemd-sysext image — rpm-ostree
layering is a last resort per the Bazzite docs (it slows every OS update and can block upgrades),
while a sysext overlays /usr at runtime, survives OS updates, and updates in one command with
no reboot. CI wraps the same RPMs below into the image, so content and channels are identical.
curl -fsSLO https://git.unom.io/unom/punktfunk/raw/branch/main/packaging/bazzite/punktfunk-sysext.sh
sudo bash punktfunk-sysext.sh install # then: sudo punktfunk-sysext update | status | remove
Full walkthrough (incl. the F43→F44 rebase behavior and migration off layering):
bazzite/README.md.
Option B — Gitea RPM registry (per-host, rpm-ostree layering)
The host's RPM is published to unom's self-hosted Gitea RPM registry (CI builds it on every
push), mirroring the Debian/apt setup. Add one repo file, install, and track
updates with rpm-ostree upgrade — no COPR account needed. Full guide: rpm/README.md.
# GPG-signed pkgs + Gitea-signed metadata → gpgcheck=1, repo_gpgcheck=1 (see rpm/README.md)
sudo tee /etc/yum.repos.d/punktfunk.repo >/dev/null <<'REPO'
[gitea-unom-bazzite]
name=punktfunk (unom, Bazzite)
baseurl=https://git.unom.io/api/packages/unom/rpm/bazzite
enabled=1
gpgcheck=1
repo_gpgcheck=1
gpgkey=https://git.unom.io/api/packages/unom/rpm/repository.key
https://git.unom.io/api/packages/unom/generic/punktfunk-keys/1/RPM-GPG-KEY-punktfunk
REPO
rpm-ostree install punktfunk && systemctl reboot
# updates: rpm-ostree upgrade && systemctl reboot
Option C — COPR (per-host, rpm-ostree install)
- Create a COPR project, enable build-from-SCM pointing at this repo, spec path
packaging/rpm/punktfunk.spec(seecopr/README.md). Under External Repositories add RPM Fusion nonfree soffmpeg-develresolves at build time. - On the Bazzite host:
# RPM Fusion (for the NVENC ffmpeg) — usually already enabled on Bazzite rpm-ostree install \ https://mirrors.rpmfusion.org/free/fedora/rpmfusion-free-release-$(rpm -E %fedora).noarch.rpm \ https://mirrors.rpmfusion.org/nonfree/fedora/rpmfusion-nonfree-release-$(rpm -E %fedora).noarch.rpm # enable the COPR + install punktfunk sudo wget -O /etc/yum.repos.d/_copr_punktfunk.repo \ https://copr.fedorainfracloud.org/coprs/enricobuehler/punktfunk/repo/fedora-$(rpm -E %fedora)/ rpm-ostree install punktfunk systemctl reboot
Option D — bootc (image-based, atomic)
Layer punktfunk into a Bazzite image once, then rebase any number of hosts onto it — no
per-host drift. See bootc/Containerfile:
podman build -t ghcr.io/<you>/bazzite-punktfunk -f packaging/bootc/Containerfile .
podman push ghcr.io/<you>/bazzite-punktfunk
# on the target:
sudo bootc switch ghcr.io/<you>/bazzite-punktfunk && systemctl reboot
First-run setup (all options)
ujust add-user-to-input-group # virtual gamepads need /dev/uinput (then re-login).
# On Bazzite use ujust, NOT `usermod -aG input` (atomic OS — it won't stick).
mkdir -p ~/.config/punktfunk
cp /usr/share/punktfunk/host.env.bazzite ~/.config/punktfunk/host.env # edit (gamescope app, etc.)
systemctl --user enable --now punktfunk-host
# Management web console (pairing + status) — pulled in by default (the host RPM Recommends it;
# `--no-install-recommends` / headless-only boxes can skip it). Enable it and read the login password:
systemctl --user enable --now punktfunk-web
journalctl --user -u punktfunk-web-init | sed -n 's/.*password generated: //p' # then open https://<host-ip>:47992
Pair a stock Moonlight client (mDNS-discovered), or connect the native punktfunk/1 client — via the
web console at https://<host-ip>:47992 or directly.
⚠️ COPR caveat: COPR's mock chroot has no
bun, so a COPR build produces onlypunktfunk+punktfunk-client— notpunktfunk-web. For the console on a COPR/bootc host, install from the Gitea RPM registry (Option B — it carriespunktfunk-web; the sysext image includes it too), which is also whybootc/Containerfileinstalls from there rather than COPR.
Why not Flatpak (for the HOST)?
The host needs unsandboxed access the zero-copy NVENC path, /dev/uinput, the PipeWire
graph and the compositor's privileged protocols — a Flatpak sandbox fights all of these.
An RPM (or the bootc layer) installs into the host system where those just work.
👉 The client is a different story — it IS shipped as a Flatpak (the only viable Steam Deck install path: SteamOS
/usris read-only and lackslibadwaita/libSDL3). Seeflatpak/README.md. The client sandbox only needs the GPU render node, Wayland, PipeWire audio, the network and hidraw — all expressible as finish-args.
Building the SRPM/RPM locally (Fedora only)
git archive --format=tar.gz --prefix=punktfunk-0.3.0/ -o ~/rpmbuild/SOURCES/punktfunk-0.3.0.tar.gz HEAD
rpmbuild -ba packaging/rpm/punktfunk.spec # needs the BuildRequires from the spec
# (0.3.0 = the spec's default %{pf_version}; the prefix and tarball name must match it)
(Not buildable on Debian/Ubuntu — use a Fedora toolbox/container or COPR.)