fix: complete the docs/→design/ and openapi→api/ rename references

The file moves (docs/ → design/, docs/api/openapi.json → api/openapi.json) landed
in d01a8fd, but the matching reference updates did not — so mgmt.rs's drift-test
`include_str!("../../../docs/api/openapi.json")` pointed at a path that no longer
exists and the host failed to build. This restores it and updates every reference:

  - mgmt.rs include_str! → ../../../api/openapi.json (fixes the build)
  - web/orval.config.ts codegen target, web/Dockerfile, .dockerignore
  - deb/rpm/Arch packaging install paths
  - CLAUDE.md, the .gitea CI workflows, code doc-comments, design-doc cross-links

docs-site route URLs (/docs/...) untouched.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
2026-06-26 11:53:02 +00:00
parent d01a8fd17a
commit f6490f4c28
45 changed files with 83 additions and 75 deletions
+14 -14
View File
@@ -43,7 +43,7 @@ Apollo is host-only. A stream flows: **nvhttp** (HTTPS pairing + serverinfo/appl
| Apollo — Audio capture, encode, transport (Windows host) | `audio.cpp`; `audio.h`; `audio.cpp`; `common.h`; `stream.cpp` | `audio.rs`; `audio/wasapi_cap.rs`; `audio/linux.rs`; `gamestream/audio.rs`; `punktfunk1.rs` |
| Apollo (Sunshine fork) — Input handling & injection | `input.cpp`; `input.cpp`; `keylayout.h`; `misc.cpp` | — |
| Apollo: App/process launch & display configuration (Windows host) | `process.cpp`; `display_device.cpp`; `process.h`; `virtual_display.h`; `misc.cpp`; `utils.cpp` | `vdisplay/sudovda.rs`; `vdisplay.rs`; `gamestream/apps.rs`; `library.rs`; `punktfunk1.rs`; `capture/wgc_relay.rs` |
| Apollo: Config, management/web UI, system tray | `config.h`; `config.cpp`; `confighttp.cpp`; `confighttp.h`; `system_tray.cpp`; `system_tray.h` | `mgmt.rs`; `mgmt_token.rs`; `main.rs`; `native_pairing.rs`; `library.rs`; `docs/windows-host.md` |
| Apollo: Config, management/web UI, system tray | `config.h`; `config.cpp`; `confighttp.cpp`; `confighttp.h`; `system_tray.cpp`; `system_tray.h` | `mgmt.rs`; `mgmt_token.rs`; `main.rs`; `native_pairing.rs`; `library.rs`; `design/windows-host.md` |
### Apollo — Protocol & streaming (RTP/FEC/ENet/RTSP/crypto)
@@ -354,7 +354,7 @@ The `formats[]` table (258-277) maps 2/6/8 channels to Stereo/5.1/7.1 with the G
- **Decouple ingest from injection via task-pool queue with lock-then-release batching** — The control-stream thread only enqueues bytes and schedules a task (src/input.cpp:1639-1643). A pool thread pops one packet, coalesces later same-type packets into it while holding the queue lock, then RELEASES the lock before the (potentially slow) SendInput/ViGEm call (src/input.cpp:1486-1520). — _For a low-latency streaming host this is the core anti-head-of-line-blocking pattern: a slow OS input call (e.g. SendInput crossing a desktop switch) never stalls the network/control thread, and bursts of mouse/scroll/controller packets collapse to one OS event per drain. punktfunk should mirror this: never call SendInput on the QUIC/control thread._
- **Type-aware packet batching with batch_result_e (batched / not_batchable / terminate_batch)** — batch() overloads (src/input.cpp:1208-1475) sum relative-mouse deltas and scroll amounts (with __builtin_add_overflow guards that terminate the batch on 16-bit overflow), take the latest absolute position, and collapse controller/touch/pen move/hover runs. terminate_batch stops at a state-changing event (button change, eventType change, active-mask change) so ordering semantics are preserved; not_batchable skips a non-matching controller but keeps scanning. — _Moonlight 'spams controller packets even when not necessary' (src/input.cpp:282). Batching cuts injected-event count under load without dropping state transitions — directly reduces input-to-screen jitter and OS overhead._
- **VK→scancode injection with normalization fallback ladder** — keyboard_update (src/platform/windows/input.cpp:608) prefers KEYEVENTF_SCANCODE using the static US-English VK_TO_SCANCODE_MAP (keylayout.h). If the client flagged the VK as non-normalized (SS_KBE_FLAG_NON_NORMALIZED) it falls back to MapVirtualKey under config::input.always_send_scancodes (excluding VK_LWIN/RWIN/PAUSE which misbehave), else sends a raw VK event. A curated switch adds KEYEVENTF_EXTENDEDKEY for the extended-key set (arrows, nav cluster, RWIN/RMENU/RCONTROL, numpad divide, apps). — _Many games read DirectInput/raw scancodes, not VK events; sending scancodes is essential for in-game key compatibility. The extended-key flag is required or arrow keys / right-modifiers misfire. This is a concrete table+logic punktfunk's Windows VK path can adopt verbatim._
- **Desktop-switch retry on every SendInput / InjectSyntheticPointerInput** — send_input (src/platform/windows/input.cpp:477) and inject_synthetic_pointer_input (line 499) retry once after calling syncThreadDesktop() (misc.cpp:251 — OpenInputDesktop(DF_ALLOWOTHERACCOUNTHOOK)+SetThreadDesktop) when the call fails and the input desktop handle changed, tracked in a thread_local _lastKnownInputDesktop. — _On Windows the input desktop changes on UAC prompts, lock screen, and Ctrl+Alt+Del (secure desktop / Winlogon). Without re-binding the thread to the new desktop, all injected input silently fails. This is exactly the secure-desktop problem area called out in punktfunk's docs/memory — Apollo solves it cheaply per-call rather than with a second process._
- **Desktop-switch retry on every SendInput / InjectSyntheticPointerInput** — send_input (src/platform/windows/input.cpp:477) and inject_synthetic_pointer_input (line 499) retry once after calling syncThreadDesktop() (misc.cpp:251 — OpenInputDesktop(DF_ALLOWOTHERACCOUNTHOOK)+SetThreadDesktop) when the call fails and the input desktop handle changed, tracked in a thread_local _lastKnownInputDesktop. — _On Windows the input desktop changes on UAC prompts, lock screen, and Ctrl+Alt+Del (secure desktop / Winlogon). Without re-binding the thread to the new desktop, all injected input silently fails. This is exactly the secure-desktop problem area called out in punktfunk's design/memory — Apollo solves it cheaply per-call rather than with a second process._
- **ViGEm dual-target gamepad with client-negotiated type selection** — alloc_gamepad (src/platform/windows/input.cpp:1175) picks X360 vs DS4 by precedence: explicit config (x360/ds4) > client-reported LI_CTYPE_PS/XBOX > motion_as_ds4 if accel/gyro present > touchpad_as_ds4 > default X360. It warns when capabilities (motion/touchpad/RGB) will be lost on X360. DS4 path packs motion, touchpad, and battery into DS4_REPORT_EX. — _DS4 is the only ViGEm target that carries gyro/accel, touchpad, and lightbar; X360 is the safe default. punktfunk already does client-negotiated pad type — Apollo's capability-driven auto-selection (motion/touchpad presence → DS4) and the explicit 'feature will be lost' warnings are a more refined policy worth porting._
- **DS4 timestamped resend loop (ds4_update_ts_and_send)** — Every DS4 report advances wTimestamp by elapsed time in 5.333µs units and re-arms a 100ms repeat_task (src/platform/windows/input.cpp:1454-1481), so the 16-bit timestamp never stalls/overflows even when no new input arrives. — _'Some applications require updated timestamp values to register DS4 input' (line 1450). Without the heartbeat, motion-aware games ignore a held DS4. Non-obvious gotcha that any DS4-emulating host must replicate._
- **Synthetic pen/touch via InjectSyntheticPointerInput with periodic refresh and slot compaction** — Per-client synthetic pointer devices (CreateSyntheticPointerDevice, Win10 1809+). Touch slots are kept contiguous via perform_touch_compaction (line 715, required by the API), edge-triggered flags (DOWN/UP/CANCELED/UPDATE) are cleared after each frame (line 900/1020), and a 50ms repeat task (ISPI_REPEAT_INTERVAL) re-injects held state because Windows auto-cancels untouched interactions after ~1s. — _Touch/pen are stateful, slot-indexed, and self-cancelling — a fundamentally different injection model than mouse/keyboard. If punktfunk grows touch/pen, this is the reference for the Windows-specific contiguity + refresh requirements._
@@ -479,7 +479,7 @@ A single static `struct tray` (l.112) holds icon path, tooltip, a fixed menu arr
- **Per-vendor encoder enum string translators** — Whole namespaces (nv/amd/qsv/vt/sw, config.cpp l.53-357) map human strings ('ultralowlatency','cqp','superfast') to encoder SDK integer constants, with low-latency presets as the DEFAULTS (e.g. amd usage = ultralowlatency l.469-471, sw preset 'superfast'/'zerolatency' l.451-453, nvenc realtime HAGS + high-power mode on by default l.457-459). — _Defaults are explicitly tuned for latency, not quality — the encoder is configured ultra-low-latency out of the box. A low-latency host's config defaults should bias the same way; this is the concrete table punktfunk can port for AMD/QSV/VT vendor parity._
- **Embedded HTTPS server sharing the host TLS identity** — confighttp uses SimpleWeb::Server<HTTPS> seeded with nvhttp.cert/pkey (confighttp.cpp l.1511) — the SAME cert the Moonlight/GameStream pairing uses — on a fixed port offset (PORT_HTTPS=1 → base+1). — _One identity, one cert, management UI and stream control on adjacent ports. punktfunk already shares its cert.pem between GameStream pairing and punktfunk/1; the lesson is the web console can reuse it rather than carrying a separate mgmt TLS story._
- **Single-string session cookie with salted-hash validation** — authenticate() (l.179) validates hex(hash(cookie + salt)) against an in-memory sessionCookie with a 15-day steady_clock expiry; login (l.1469) rand_alphabet(64) the raw cookie and stores only its hash. checkIPOrigin gates by pc/lan/wan BEFORE auth. — _Contrast with punktfunk's mgmt API (bearer token in ~/.config/punktfunk/mgmt-token + web login gate). Apollo's cookie+IP-origin model is simpler for a desktop single-operator host and avoids a static long-lived token; worth considering for the web console's UX._
- **Windows service↔UI self-elevation handshake** — config::parse (l.1490-1534): a non-admin Start-Menu shortcut self-relaunches as admin (ShellExecuteExW 'runas' --shortcut-admin l.1511), starts the service, wait_for_ui_ready() polls the Win32 TCP table for the LISTEN socket (entry_handler.cpp l.236), then launch_ui(), and returns 1 so the shortcut process never starts a stream. — _This is the mature answer to the exact problem punktfunk's Windows host hit (docs/windows-host.md 'secure-desktop two-process design', Session-0 vs interactive session). Apollo solves UI-launch-from-service cleanly; the TCP-table readiness poll is directly portable._
- **Windows service↔UI self-elevation handshake** — config::parse (l.1490-1534): a non-admin Start-Menu shortcut self-relaunches as admin (ShellExecuteExW 'runas' --shortcut-admin l.1511), starts the service, wait_for_ui_ready() polls the Win32 TCP table for the LISTEN socket (entry_handler.cpp l.236), then launch_ui(), and returns 1 so the shortcut process never starts a stream. — _This is the mature answer to the exact problem punktfunk's Windows host hit (design/windows-host.md 'secure-desktop two-process design', Session-0 vs interactive session). Apollo solves UI-launch-from-service cleanly; the TCP-table readiness poll is directly portable._
- **Tray thread DACL hardening for SYSTEM-context survival** — init_tray() (l.143-197) adds an EXPLICIT_ACCESS ACE granting SYNCHRONIZE to Everyone on the current thread handle before registering the icon, and busy-waits for GetShellWindow() (l.201) so the icon registers reliably across logoff/logon. — _When the host runs as a Windows service (SYSTEM), Explorer can't open the thread to detect termination → ghost tray icons forever. punktfunk's Windows host, if it ever runs as a service with a tray, needs this exact DACL fix._
- **JSON-list config values parsed via ptree wrapping** — Multi-line bracketed values (global_prep_cmd, server_cmd, dd_mode_remapping) are extracted as raw strings by the flat parser, wrapped in a synthetic JSON object, then parsed by boost ptree (list_prep_cmd_f l.949, mode_remapping_from_view l.411). — _A pragmatic hybrid: flat key=value for the human-editable 90%, embedded JSON for structured fields, without committing to full-JSON config. Shows how to grow a flat config without a rewrite._
@@ -680,7 +680,7 @@ Both transports use the persistent `AudioCapSlot` (gamestream/audio.rs:251-257)
### Input handling & injection — 🔴 Apollo ahead
For the Windows host specifically, Apollo is ahead on input breadth and robustness. Apollo covers mouse (rel+abs), keyboard (with a static US-layout VK→scancode table for game compatibility), Unicode text, scroll, **touch + pen via CreateSyntheticPointerDevice**, and **both X360 and DS4** gamepads with rumble/LED/motion/touchpad/battery feedback (Apollo src/platform/windows/input.cpp). punktfunk's Windows host covers mouse/keyboard/scroll/X360-only; touch and pen are explicit no-ops (sendinput.rs:231-237), there is no Unicode text path (gamestream/input.rs:83-84), and only the Xbox 360 virtual pad exists on Windows. Apollo also has the more efficient secure-desktop model (retry-only) vs punktfunk's per-event reattach (sendinput.rs:97), and Apollo's task-pool queue + type-aware batching (Apollo src/input.cpp:1481-1571, 1208-1475) coalesces input spam off the network thread — punktfunk's GameStream path injects inline on the ENet thread (control.rs:207-211) with no batching anywhere. punktfunk's design is cleaner and its m3 path's session-end held-key release + backend-follow logic is genuinely nicer than Apollo, but those are punktfunk/1-specific; on the shared Windows-host injection surface Apollo is the more complete, battle-tested implementation. punktfunk's docs/windows-secure-desktop.md already flags the retry-only refactor as planned-but-unshipped, confirming the gap.
For the Windows host specifically, Apollo is ahead on input breadth and robustness. Apollo covers mouse (rel+abs), keyboard (with a static US-layout VK→scancode table for game compatibility), Unicode text, scroll, **touch + pen via CreateSyntheticPointerDevice**, and **both X360 and DS4** gamepads with rumble/LED/motion/touchpad/battery feedback (Apollo src/platform/windows/input.cpp). punktfunk's Windows host covers mouse/keyboard/scroll/X360-only; touch and pen are explicit no-ops (sendinput.rs:231-237), there is no Unicode text path (gamestream/input.rs:83-84), and only the Xbox 360 virtual pad exists on Windows. Apollo also has the more efficient secure-desktop model (retry-only) vs punktfunk's per-event reattach (sendinput.rs:97), and Apollo's task-pool queue + type-aware batching (Apollo src/input.cpp:1481-1571, 1208-1475) coalesces input spam off the network thread — punktfunk's GameStream path injects inline on the ENet thread (control.rs:207-211) with no batching anywhere. punktfunk's design is cleaner and its m3 path's session-end held-key release + backend-follow logic is genuinely nicer than Apollo, but those are punktfunk/1-specific; on the shared Windows-host injection surface Apollo is the more complete, battle-tested implementation. punktfunk's design/windows-secure-desktop.md already flags the retry-only refactor as planned-but-unshipped, confirming the gap.
**How punktfunk does it.**
@@ -748,7 +748,7 @@ For the Windows host specifically, Apollo is clearly ahead on this subsystem. Ap
- punktfunk has TWO app surfaces by design: the GameStream apps.json catalog (Moonlight compat) AND a richer punktfunk/1 library (Steam local scan + custom store + CDN art + uniform GameEntry grid). Apollo has only the apps.json catalog because it ships no client.
- punktfunk's launch security model is deliberately client-can't-inject: the client sends only a store-qualified id and the host resolves it against its OWN library (library.rs:394-412), with steam appid validated digits-only. Apollo trusts its own apps.json cmds (it has no untrusted remote launch id).
- punktfunk keeps NO async on the per-frame path; the SudoVDA watchdog pinger and capture are native threads. Apollo's libdisplaydevice RetryScheduler is its own machinery; punktfunk has no equivalent scheduler by choice (yet — see candidate improvements).
- punktfunk's Windows virtual display is the SOLE primary output (isolate_displays + CDS_SET_PRIMARY) specifically to capture the secure/Winlogon desktop — a deliberate, documented design (docs/windows-secure-desktop.md) that goes beyond what stock Apollo needs.
- punktfunk's Windows virtual display is the SOLE primary output (isolate_displays + CDS_SET_PRIMARY) specifically to capture the secure/Winlogon desktop — a deliberate, documented design (design/windows-secure-desktop.md) that goes beyond what stock Apollo needs.
**Transfer candidates from Apollo (6):** _Actually launch the app/game on Windows (CreateProcessAsUserW into the user session)_, _Display-config apply/revert with a retry scheduler and guaranteed revert on disconnect_, _Set HDR on the virtual display and advertise IsHdrSupported when the client requests it_, _Per-(app,client) stable virtual-display GUID instead of one fixed MONITOR_GUID_, _Inject per-app launch env (client res/fps/HDR/audio + status) for launch scripts_, _auto_detach heuristic for launcher-style apps (Steam/UWP) that exit immediately_ — see Part 4.
@@ -765,7 +765,7 @@ On the API itself punktfunk is arguably ahead (versioned `/api/v1`, compile-time
punktfunk splits the control surface into three pieces and deliberately keeps them OUT of the host binary where Apollo bundles them in.
##### 1. Management plane = a versioned REST API only (`crates/punktfunk-host/src/mgmt.rs`)
- An axum `Router` (`mgmt.rs:166` `fn app`) under `/api/v1`, single source of truth shared between the live server and the `openapi` subcommand (`mgmt.rs:195` `api_router_parts`, `main.rs:86`). The OpenAPI 3.1 doc is generated at compile time with `utoipa` and a checked-in copy is drift-tested against `docs/api/openapi.json` (`mgmt.rs:1582` `openapi_document_is_complete_and_checked_in`). This is a real maturity advantage over Apollo, which has no machine-readable API spec.
- An axum `Router` (`mgmt.rs:166` `fn app`) under `/api/v1`, single source of truth shared between the live server and the `openapi` subcommand (`mgmt.rs:195` `api_router_parts`, `main.rs:86`). The OpenAPI 3.1 doc is generated at compile time with `utoipa` and a checked-in copy is drift-tested against `api/openapi.json` (`mgmt.rs:1582` `openapi_document_is_complete_and_checked_in`). This is a real maturity advantage over Apollo, which has no machine-readable API spec.
- Routes: host info/capabilities/port map (`mgmt.rs:590`), live status (`mgmt.rs:671`), paired GameStream clients list/unpair (`mgmt.rs:707`,`752`), the GameStream PIN flow (`mgmt.rs:789`,`814`), the native punktfunk/1 pairing surface — arm/disarm/status/list/unpair (`mgmt.rs:870`-`994`), **delegated pairing approval** via a pending-device queue (`mgmt.rs:1011`,`1049`,`1094`), session stop + force-IDR (`mgmt.rs:1120`,`1144`), and game-library CRUD (`mgmt.rs:1171`-`1252`).
- **HTTPS always, even on loopback** (`mgmt.rs:75` `run`): it runs the rustls handshake itself via tokio-rustls so it can surface the verified peer cert to handlers (`mgmt.rs:115` `serve_https`), reusing the host's persistent identity cert that clients already pin (`mgmt.rs:90`).
- **Dual auth** (`mgmt.rs:518` `require_auth`): a paired native client authenticates by its **mTLS certificate fingerprint** (matched against the native paired store, no token needed); everyone else (the web console / admin) uses a bearer token compared in constant time (`mgmt.rs:551` `token_eq` via SHA-256 digest compare). `/api/v1/health` is the only unauthenticated route. This is stronger than Apollo's single-global-session-cookie scheme (Apollo `confighttp.cpp` has exactly one `std::string sessionCookie`).
@@ -784,7 +784,7 @@ A token always exists with zero operator steps: env `PUNKTFUNK_MGMT_TOKEN` wins,
There is no system tray, no balloon notifications, and no "open the UI in the browser" entry point anywhere in `crates/punktfunk-host`. Apollo has a full cross-platform tray (`system_tray.cpp`) with state-driven icon/notification updates and menu callbacks.
##### 6. Windows launch story = scripts, not in-binary
The two-process secure-desktop design exists for *capture* (`main.rs:204` `wgc-helper` subcommand + `capture/wgc_relay.rs` `CreateProcessAsUserW`), but the service/desktop launch dance is handled by external scripts (scheduled task -> PsExec64 -> launch.vbs -> host-run.cmd; `docs/windows-host.md:77-96`). punktfunk has no in-binary service install, no self-elevation, no "launch UI in browser", and no tray — all of which Apollo bakes into `config.cpp`/`entry_handler.cpp`/`system_tray.cpp`.
The two-process secure-desktop design exists for *capture* (`main.rs:204` `wgc-helper` subcommand + `capture/wgc_relay.rs` `CreateProcessAsUserW`), but the service/desktop launch dance is handled by external scripts (scheduled task -> PsExec64 -> launch.vbs -> host-run.cmd; `design/windows-host.md:77-96`). punktfunk has no in-binary service install, no self-elevation, no "launch UI in browser", and no tray — all of which Apollo bakes into `config.cpp`/`entry_handler.cpp`/`system_tray.cpp`.
**Intentional divergences (by design, not gaps):**
@@ -1555,14 +1555,14 @@ punktfunk's **secure-desktop / desktop-switch capture recovery is genuinely matu
##### Where punktfunk is weaker / missing / fragile
1. **No real Windows service — relies on a PsExec scheduled task.** The launch chain is a scheduled task → `PsExec64 -s -i 1``wscript.exe launch.vbs` → hidden `host-run.cmd` (`docs/windows-host.md:78-84`). There is **no `SERVICE_CONTROL_SESSIONCHANGE` relaunch** — the doc even lists it as unimplemented "step 6" (`docs/windows-secure-desktop.md:89`). PsExec is a 3rd-party SysInternals tool, not redistributable cleanly, and `-s -i 1` hard-codes session 1. None of the launch scripts (`launch.vbs`, `host-run.cmd`) are checked into the repo (only `scripts/headless/win-build.cmd` exists). This is the single biggest fragility vs Apollo's `sunshinesvc.cpp`.
1. **No real Windows service — relies on a PsExec scheduled task.** The launch chain is a scheduled task → `PsExec64 -s -i 1``wscript.exe launch.vbs` → hidden `host-run.cmd` (`design/windows-host.md:78-84`). There is **no `SERVICE_CONTROL_SESSIONCHANGE` relaunch** — the doc even lists it as unimplemented "step 6" (`design/windows-secure-desktop.md:89`). PsExec is a 3rd-party SysInternals tool, not redistributable cleanly, and `-s -i 1` hard-codes session 1. None of the launch scripts (`launch.vbs`, `host-run.cmd`) are checked into the repo (only `scripts/headless/win-build.cmd` exists). This is the single biggest fragility vs Apollo's `sunshinesvc.cpp`.
2. **No nvprefs / NvAPI at all.** `grep` for `nvprefs|NvAPI|DRS_|PREFERRED_PSTATE|DXPRESENT` across the host returns nothing. No PREFERRED_PSTATE_MAX for the encoder, no OGL_CPL_PREFER_DXPRESENT (so GL/Vulkan fullscreen apps may not be capturable via WGC/DDA), and no undo-file crash safety.
3. **No DXGI GPU-preference / output-reparenting hook.** No MinHook of `NtGdiDdDDIGetCachedHybridQueryValue`. On a hybrid/Optimus box DXGI can reparent the SudoVDA output onto the render GPU and break DDA. punktfunk's "search all adapters" partly papers over this but does not prevent the reparenting itself.
4. **mDNS uses the cross-platform `mdns-sd` crate, not Windows-native `DnsServiceRegister`** (`discovery.rs:17`). It works, but it does NOT carry Apollo's RFC-1035 empty-TXT fix — and the GameStream/Moonlight mDNS path on Windows is unverified (`docs/windows-host.md:46`). A non-RFC-compliant TXT can be rejected by Apple's resolver.
4. **mDNS uses the cross-platform `mdns-sd` crate, not Windows-native `DnsServiceRegister`** (`discovery.rs:17`). It works, but it does NOT carry Apollo's RFC-1035 empty-TXT fix — and the GameStream/Moonlight mDNS path on Windows is unverified (`design/windows-host.md:46`). A non-RFC-compliant TXT can be rejected by Apple's resolver.
5. **No stream-start system tuning.** No `NtSetTimerResolution`/`timeBeginPeriod`, no `DwmEnableMMCSS`, no `SetPriorityClass(HIGH_PRIORITY_CLASS)`, no `SetThreadExecutionState(ES_DISPLAY_REQUIRED)`, no WLAN media-streaming mode, no Mouse-Keys-on-headless trick. (Linux has none of this either, but on Windows these are real latency/jitter levers Apollo proves out.)
6. **No `factory->IsCurrent()` per-frame check.** punktfunk reacts to errors from `AcquireNextFrame` but does not proactively detect HDR/topology changes the way Apollo does each frame (`display_base.cpp:235`) — it relies on ACCESS_LOST firing, which it usually does, but IsCurrent is the cleaner signal.
7. **No `is_user_session_locked()` / CCD pre-flight.** Before a mode-set or isolation, Apollo checks `WTSQuerySessionInformationW` + `SetDisplayConfig(SDC_VALIDATE)` (`utils.cpp:184-237`); punktfunk just attempts and handles failure, which can thrash the display during a lock.
8. **Clock epoch is `SystemTime::now()` (`dxgi.rs:1530`), not `GetSystemTimePreciseAsFileTime`.** The doc itself flags this as a cross-machine-latency risk (`docs/windows-host.md:284-286`); std SystemTime on Windows historically has coarser (~115 ms) resolution than the precise FILETIME API, which can corrupt the ClockProbe/ClockEcho skew handshake.
8. **Clock epoch is `SystemTime::now()` (`dxgi.rs:1530`), not `GetSystemTimePreciseAsFileTime`.** The doc itself flags this as a cross-machine-latency risk (`design/windows-host.md:284-286`); std SystemTime on Windows historically has coarser (~115 ms) resolution than the precise FILETIME API, which can corrupt the ClockProbe/ClockEcho skew handshake.
#### Transfer opportunities
@@ -1772,7 +1772,7 @@ GameStream `SO_SNDBUF`), **#8** (move GameStream input injection off the ENet se
*Area:* `cmp:input` · *Windows-host:* yes · *Severity:* high · *Effort:* small
- **Apollo does:** send_input() / inject_synthetic_pointer_input() call SendInput FIRST, and only on failure (0 injected) re-run syncThreadDesktop() (OpenInputDesktop(DF_ALLOWOTHERACCOUNTHOOK)+SetThreadDesktop) and retry once, tracking the desktop in a thread_local _lastKnownInputDesktop — src/platform/windows/input.cpp:477,499 + src/platform/windows/misc.cpp:251
- **punktfunk gap:** SendInputInjector::inject() calls reattach_input_desktop() (an OpenInputDesktop+SetThreadDesktop+CloseDesktop) at the TOP of EVERY event — crates/punktfunk-host/src/inject/sendinput.rs:97,50-69. This is a syscall triple per mouse-move; punktfunk's own docs/windows-secure-desktop.md:78-80 lists this exact refactor (step 2) as planned but unshipped.
- **punktfunk gap:** SendInputInjector::inject() calls reattach_input_desktop() (an OpenInputDesktop+SetThreadDesktop+CloseDesktop) at the TOP of EVERY event — crates/punktfunk-host/src/inject/sendinput.rs:97,50-69. This is a syscall triple per mouse-move; punktfunk's own design/windows-secure-desktop.md:78-80 lists this exact refactor (step 2) as planned but unshipped.
- **Proposal:** Inject first; cache the HDESK thread-local; only on a 0/partial SendInput result call reattach_input_desktop() and retry once. Use DF_ALLOWOTHERACCOUNTHOOK in the OpenInputDesktop access (sendinput.rs:52-56 currently passes DESKTOP_CONTROL_FLAGS(0)) so the secure desktop is reachable. Keeps the steady-state hot path to a single SendInput call.
#### 2. Detect resolution/format change on the acquire hot path, not only during rebuild
@@ -1846,7 +1846,7 @@ GameStream `SO_SNDBUF`), **#8** (move GameStream input injection off the ENet se
*Area:* `cmp:config-management` · *Windows-host:* yes · *Severity:* high · *Effort:* medium
- **Apollo does:** system_tray.cpp builds a single static tray struct with a menu (Open/Force-stop/Reset-display/Restart/Quit, l.112-141) and pushes state changes from the streaming pipeline — update_tray_playing/pausing/stopped/launch_error/require_pin/paired/client_connected (l.238-412) each swap the icon + raise a balloon notification; init_tray hardens the thread DACL so the icon survives running as SYSTEM (l.143-204); a 50 ms polling thread drives it (tray_thread_worker l.415).
- **punktfunk gap:** No tray code exists anywhere in crates/punktfunk-host (grep for tray/notify-rust/balloon returns nothing). On Windows the host runs windowless as SYSTEM in Session 1 via external scripts (docs/windows-host.md:77-84) with the only operator feedback being a redirected log file — there is no visible, clickable status/control surface for a desktop user.
- **punktfunk gap:** No tray code exists anywhere in crates/punktfunk-host (grep for tray/notify-rust/balloon returns nothing). On Windows the host runs windowless as SYSTEM in Session 1 via external scripts (design/windows-host.md:77-84) with the only operator feedback being a redirected log file — there is no visible, clickable status/control surface for a desktop user.
- **Proposal:** Add an optional system-tray plane behind a feature/flag using a Rust tray crate (e.g. tray-icon) spawned on its own native thread (no async on the per-frame path). Drive it from the existing AppState atomics/locks already exposed by mgmt.rs get_status (streaming/audio_streaming/pin_pending/session) — poll or push on state change to swap icon + show balloons (connected, pairing PIN, launch error). Menu items call the SAME primitives the API uses (stop_session, force_idr, native arm-pairing, quit). On Windows replicate Apollo's thread-DACL hardening so the icon shows when launched as SYSTEM in the interactive session.
#### 11. Treat S_OK-with-no-change frames as timeouts via DXGI update flags
@@ -1923,7 +1923,7 @@ GameStream `SO_SNDBUF`), **#8** (move GameStream input injection off the ENet se
*Area:* `cmp:config-management` · *Windows-host:* yes · *Severity:* high · *Effort:* large
- **Apollo does:** config.cpp:1490-1534 handles the Windows shortcut/service launch dance inside the binary: --shortcut/--shortcut-admin handling, ShellExecuteExW(runas, --shortcut-admin) to self-elevate when the service isn't running, waits for the service, wait_for_ui_ready(), launch_ui(), then returns 1 so the foreground process does NOT also start a stream host. This is Sunshine/Apollo's mature service<->UI two-process split that makes one-click launch work.
- **punktfunk gap:** punktfunk has no service-install / self-elevation / interactive-session bring-up in the binary. Deployment is documented as a manual chain of external scripts — scheduled task -> PsExec64 -i 1 -> launch.vbs -> host-run.cmd (docs/windows-host.md:77-96) — fragile and operator-hostile. main.rs has no install/service subcommand.
- **punktfunk gap:** punktfunk has no service-install / self-elevation / interactive-session bring-up in the binary. Deployment is documented as a manual chain of external scripts — scheduled task -> PsExec64 -i 1 -> launch.vbs -> host-run.cmd (design/windows-host.md:77-96) — fragile and operator-hostile. main.rs has no install/service subcommand.
- **Proposal:** Add `punktfunk-host install`/`uninstall`/`service` subcommands (Windows-gated) that register a service or an Interactive/Highest scheduled task to launch the host in Session 1 (the documented requirement for DXGI duplication + SendInput), and the self-elevate-if-not-running shortcut path. Reuse the existing capture/wgc_relay CreateProcessAsUserW machinery already in the crate. This codifies the script chain into the binary without touching the per-frame path or core.
#### 21. Composite the moved cursor onto a clean copy even when DDA returns no new desktop frame
@@ -1962,7 +1962,7 @@ GameStream `SO_SNDBUF`), **#8** (move GameStream input injection off the ENet se
*Area:* `win:system-secure-desktop` · *Windows-host:* yes · *Severity:* high · *Effort:* large
- **Apollo does:** SunshineSvc.exe runs as LocalSystem in Session 0, loops on WTSGetActiveConsoleSessionId, clones its own token with DuplicateTokenEx(TokenPrimary)+SetTokenInformation(TokenSessionId) and CreateProcessAsUserW into winsta0\\default inside a per-session job object (JOB_OBJECT_LIMIT_KILL_ON_JOB_CLOSE|BREAKAWAY_OK); opts into SERVICE_ACCEPT_SESSIONCHANGE and on WTS_CONSOLE_CONNECT terminates+relaunches the host in the new session (tools/sunshinesvc.cpp:95,111,239,256,267,276-294)
- **punktfunk gap:** punktfunk has no Windows service; launch is a PsExec64 -s -i 1 scheduled task hard-coded to session 1 (docs/windows-host.md:78-84), with the SERVICE_CONTROL_SESSIONCHANGE relaunch listed as unimplemented step 6 (docs/windows-secure-desktop.md:89). Launch scripts are not even in the repo.
- **punktfunk gap:** punktfunk has no Windows service; launch is a PsExec64 -s -i 1 scheduled task hard-coded to session 1 (design/windows-host.md:78-84), with the SERVICE_CONTROL_SESSIONCHANGE relaunch listed as unimplemented step 6 (design/windows-secure-desktop.md:89). Launch scripts are not even in the repo.
- **Proposal:** Add a small Rust service binary (new crate or punktfunk-host `service` subcommand) using windows::Win32::System::Services (RegisterServiceCtrlHandlerEx, StartServiceCtrlDispatcher) that mirrors sunshinesvc.cpp: WTSGetActiveConsoleSessionId -> DuplicateTokenEx+SetTokenInformation(TokenSessionId) -> CreateProcessAsUserW(lpDesktop=winsta0\\default) into a kill-on-close job, accept SERVICE_ACCEPT_SESSIONCHANGE, and relaunch the host on a genuine console-session change. Ship an installer and drop the PsExec dependency.
#### 25. Elevate capture/encode/send thread priority on the host hot path
+1 -1
View File
@@ -40,7 +40,7 @@ the GPU/compositor stack of the box it runs on). What is:
| Image | Source | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| `git.unom.io/unom/punktfunk-web` | `web/Dockerfile` (repo-root context — orval needs `docs/api/openapi.json`) | Nitro `bun` bundle; `PORT` (3000) and `PUNKTFUNK_MGMT_URL` env at runtime |
| `git.unom.io/unom/punktfunk-web` | `web/Dockerfile` (repo-root context — orval needs `api/openapi.json`) | Nitro `bun` bundle; `PORT` (3000) and `PUNKTFUNK_MGMT_URL` env at runtime |
| `git.unom.io/unom/punktfunk-docs` | `docs-site/Dockerfile` | This site; `PORT` (3000) |
| `git.unom.io/unom/punktfunk-rust-ci` | `ci/rust-ci.Dockerfile` | Ubuntu 26.04 + FFmpeg 8/PipeWire/GL/GBM dev libs + a libcuda **link stub** (driver userspace, no kernel module) + pinned rustup — the container `ci.yml`'s Rust job runs in |
+2 -2
View File
@@ -51,7 +51,7 @@ back — i.e. the Windows analogue of the **GTK4 Linux client** (`clients/linux`
which is the architectural template. The Windows client is close to a 1:1 port of the Linux client
with the platform layers swapped.
## Locked decisions (from the Windows-host/client plan, `docs/windows-host.md` + project memory)
## Locked decisions (from the Windows-host/client plan, `design/windows-host.md` + project memory)
- **Pure Rust.** `windows-rs` + **Windows App SDK "Reactor"** (WinUI 3 from Rust, merged windows-rs
PR #4479). No C++/C#. De-risk Reactor + `SwapChainPanel` FIRST — it's the only novel/uncertain
@@ -165,6 +165,6 @@ Windows client should mirror it:
- **Core client API:** `crates/punktfunk-core/src/client.rs` (`NativeClient`).
- **Protocol:** `crates/punktfunk-core/src/quic.rs` (`Hello.video_caps`, `Welcome.bit_depth`,
`VIDEO_CAP_10BIT`/`VIDEO_CAP_HDR`).
- **Full Windows plan + SudoVDA/host details:** `docs/windows-host.md`.
- **Full Windows plan + SudoVDA/host details:** `design/windows-host.md`.
- **Host HDR conversion (for the inverse math):** `crates/punktfunk-host/src/capture/dxgi.rs`
(`HDR_PS`, `HdrConverter`) + `crates/punktfunk-host/src/encode/nvenc.rs` (BT.2020/PQ VUI).
+1 -1
View File
@@ -428,5 +428,5 @@ This file replaces five docs (recoverable from git history):
- `windows-host-rewrite-game-capture-bug.md` (the GB1 investigation + fix) — **fixed**; the resolution is
§2.5 (capture). The full investigation narrative is in git history.
(The older `docs/windows-host.md`, a pre-rewrite implementation plan from 2026-06-22, is a separate
(The older `design/windows-host.md`, a pre-rewrite implementation plan from 2026-06-22, is a separate
lineage and is left as-is.)